Inspection Negotiation

Inspection Repair Requests: How Ocala Sellers Should Negotiate


The inspection is where a clean contract turns into a second negotiation. A buyer hands you a list and a dollar number, and how you answer decides whether you keep your price, give it away, or lose the deal. Here is what you actually owe under a Florida AS-IS contract, which items are worth saying yes to, and the exact way I respond for my Ocala sellers.

15Default FL inspection period, in days
4Ways to answer a repair request
$0You owe on an AS-IS contract
3%Listing fee, cancel anytime

The short answer

A repair request is the buyer asking you to fix items, credit money, or cut the price after their inspection. On Florida's most common contract, the AS-IS version, you have no legal duty to repair anything, so your four options are to make the repairs, offer a closing credit, reduce the price, or decline. Say yes to safety, structural, water, and major system items. Push back on cosmetics and ordinary wear.

How I handle it: I answer every request on paper with contractor numbers and your net sheet in hand, so you concede only what keeps the deal and protects your price.

The Basics

What is a repair request, and when does it land?

After you accept an offer, the buyer orders a home inspection and gets back a report that flags everything from a cracked roof tile to a worn dishwasher. From that report the buyer sends you a repair request, sometimes called an inspection addendum or a request to remedy. It lists the items they want handled and usually asks for repairs, a cash credit at closing, or a price reduction.

Timing is controlled by the contract. Most Ocala homes sell on the FAR/BAR AS-IS Residential Contract, the standard form from Florida Realtors and The Florida Bar, current revision 2/26. Its default inspection period is 15 calendar days from the effective date. During that window the buyer can cancel for any reason and get their deposit back, which is exactly where their leverage comes from. Any deal you strike on repairs has to be written into a signed addendum before that period ends. A text that says you will fix the roof is not enforceable. Paragraph 18 of the contract requires changes to be in writing and signed by both sides.

There are two contract flavors, and the difference matters. On the AS-IS contract you owe no repairs at all. On the older FAR/BAR Standard contract, the seller agrees up front to fix certain items up to a capped dollar amount. Know which one you signed before you answer a single line of the request. If you are not sure, that is the first question for your agent.

The Rules

What does an Ocala seller actually have to fix?

On an AS-IS contract, nothing. The seller commits to zero repairs, and the only duty is to keep the home in substantially the same condition it was in on the effective date, so you cannot let a working system break and leave it. Whatever the inspector finds, you are not contractually required to touch it.

That sounds like all the power sits with you. It does not, and here is the catch most sellers miss. The buyer can still walk during the inspection period and keep their deposit, so "no" can cost you the whole deal and send you back to market. In a Marion County market with more than 2,100 active listings as of October 2026 and homes taking months rather than weeks to sell, a lost buyer is expensive. Redfin put the Ocala median sale price near $274,869 in September 2026, down about 2.8% from a year earlier, so this is not a market where buyers line up to replace the one you just lost.

There is one more exception that overrides the AS-IS language entirely: the buyer's lender. If the buyer is financing, the appraiser or underwriter can require specific repairs before the loan funds, often an active roof leak, exposed wiring, missing handrails, or visible mold. Those are not optional. If you want the sale to close, lender-called items get done regardless of what the contract says about AS-IS. This is general information, not legal advice, so your closing agent and the buyer's lender should confirm what their file requires.

Your Options

The four ways to answer a repair request

Every response you can give fits into one of four buckets. The right one depends on the item, the loan, and how badly each side wants the deal. Here is how they compare.

Response Best when The catch
Make the repairsLender requires it, or the fix is quick and cheapYou manage contractors and quality on a deadline
Closing creditBuyer would rather do the work their wayLimited by the buyer's loan concession cap
Price reductionYou want the lowest raw cost to youLowers your recorded sale price and the comps
DeclineItem is cosmetic or ordinary wearBuyer can cancel and keep their deposit

Most of my deals settle on a closing credit, because it keeps your timeline clean and lets the buyer handle the work on their schedule. A credit is money off what the buyer owes at the table, not a cut to the contract price, so the home still records at the full number. That protects your appraisal and the next comp in the neighborhood. The difference between a credit and a price cut is the same math I walk through in seller concessions in Florida, and one caution carries over: a credit cannot exceed the buyer's actual closing costs, and it has to fit their loan program's limit or underwriting strips it out.

A Worked Example

A real repair request, line by line

Say you are under contract at $300,000 on a southwest Ocala home. The inspection comes back and the buyer sends a request totaling $12,400. Do not react to the total. Break it apart, because the list almost always mixes real issues with padding.

Item flagged Buyer asked for My read
Active leak at water heater$1,800Real. Water and a likely lender flag. Address it.
Missing GFCI outlets, kitchen and baths$600Real and cheap safety item. Credit or fix.
Three cracked roof tiles$1,500Real but a targeted repair, not a reroof.
"Roof is 16 years old, replace it"$7,000Age is not a defect. Decline, offer the tile fix.
Dated cabinet hinges, scuffed paint$1,500Cosmetic. Decline.
What I would agree toabout $3,900The safety, water, and real roof items only

Instead of a $12,400 giveaway, a reasonable answer is roughly $3,900, offered as a single closing credit so the buyer handles the work after closing and you keep the recorded price at $300,000. You conceded the items that are real, carry safety or water risk, and could trip the lender. You held the line on roof age, which is a maintenance fact and not a defect, and on cosmetics, which every buyer inherits in a resale home. That is the whole skill: separate the deal-killers from the wish list and pay only for the first group.

The Priorities

Which repairs are worth saying yes to?

Buyers are most likely to fight for safety, then structural and system items, and almost never win on cosmetics. Use that order. Here is how I triage a request from first dollar to last.

  • Say yes to safety and water. Active leaks, exposed or ungrounded wiring, gas issues, missing smoke detectors, and anything a lender will call. These are cheap relative to a dead deal and they are what buyers dig in on.
  • Consider structural and major systems. Foundation movement, a failing HVAC, a water heater at end of life, or a panel problem. Get a licensed contractor's number before you agree, because the buyer's estimate is often the high one.
  • Negotiate the roof on condition, not age. A specific leak or cracked tiles are fair game. A blanket "replace the roof because it is old" is not a defect, and in Florida roof age is really an insurance question, covered below.
  • Decline cosmetics and ordinary wear. Paint, worn carpet, dated fixtures, minor cracks, and "recommend monitoring" notes are not repair items. The buyer saw the home before they offered.
  • Set a floor. I do not negotiate individual items under a small threshold, usually a few hundred dollars. Bundling tiny asks just drags out the back and forth and trains the buyer to keep nibbling.

If the request is enormous and the home genuinely needs work, the better question may be whether you should have listed it differently in the first place. That is the decision in selling your Ocala home as-is or fixing it up first, and the return math is in repairs before selling your Ocala home.

The Ocala Factor

Why roof age and insurance drive so many Ocala repair fights

In Florida, the roof line on an inspection report is rarely about the roof leaking. It is about whether the buyer can get affordable insurance, and that is a real concern, not a negotiating trick. Knowing the rules keeps you from overpaying on a roof that does not need replacing.

Older homes trigger a 4-point inspection, a separate insurance document covering four systems: roof, electrical, plumbing, and HVAC. Citizens, the state-backed insurer, generally requires a 4-point on homes over 20 years old to write or renew a policy, and many private carriers draw the line at 30 years. A rough 4-point can scare a buyer more than the home inspection itself.

On roof age specifically, Florida law is friendlier to sellers than most people think. An insurer cannot refuse a policy on a roof under 15 years old based on age alone. For a roof 15 years or older, the insurer must allow an inspection first, and cannot decline solely on age if that inspection shows at least five years of useful life left. Citizens publishes its own thresholds, around 25 years for shingle roofs and 50 years for tile, slate, concrete, and metal. So a 16-year-old shingle roof in good shape is often insurable, which is exactly why "it is old, replace it" is a weak repair demand.

The counter-move is cheap. A wind mitigation inspection is optional and documents features like roof-to-wall connections and shutters on the state form, OIR-B1-1802, which was updated effective April 1, 2026. Wind-mitigation credits can cut the windstorm part of a buyer's premium by roughly $300 to $600 a year, and the report stays valid for five years. A current wind-mit report in the buyer's hands can do more to save a deal than a price cut, because it attacks the real worry, which is the monthly insurance cost at today's rates. With the 30-year fixed mortgage averaging 7.32% in Freddie Mac's October 22, 2026 survey, buyers are watching every line of their payment, insurance included.

Avoid These

Mistakes that cost Ocala sellers money after the inspection

  • Reacting to the total instead of the list. A $12,000 request is not a $12,000 problem. Price each line and most of them fall away.
  • Agreeing by text or email. If it is not in a signed addendum before the inspection period ends, it is not binding. Get it in writing every time.
  • Using the buyer's repair estimates. The buyer's contractor number is almost always the ceiling. Get your own licensed bid before you commit to a dollar figure.
  • Paying for roof age. Replacing an insurable roof to satisfy a buyer who confused age with condition can cost you five figures you did not owe.
  • Doing repairs when a credit is cleaner. A rushed repair you manage can go wrong and still get re-inspected. A credit often closes faster with less risk to you.
  • Treating it as personal. A cooperative, numbers-first response keeps good buyers at the table. A flat "no" on everything is how deals die in a market where the next buyer may not come quickly.

If your home has already stalled and the inspection request is the latest in a string of problems, the issue may be upstream. Start with why your Ocala home is not selling and how to price your house in Ocala.

How I Handle This For My Sellers

How I keep the inspection from eating your price

The contract is signed, the buyer is emotionally in, and the inspection is the one place left for them to claw money back. My job is to make sure every dollar you give up is a decision backed by a number, not a flinch.

  • A pre-listing plan so there are fewer surprises. When it makes sense, I have the home reviewed before we list, so the real issues are known and priced in, not sprung on us later. See when a pre-listing inspection saves you money.
  • Line-by-line triage with contractor bids. I sort the request into safety, systems, roof, and cosmetics, get my own licensed estimates, and bring you a counter that concedes only the items that are real.
  • Credit versus repair versus price cut, modeled on your net sheet. You see the actual dollar effect of each path before we answer, the same way I model it in your seller net sheet.
  • The insurance angle handled. On roof-age fights I line up the wind mitigation and 4-point facts so a buyer's premium worry does not turn into a reroof you never owed.
  • Everything in a signed addendum, on time. No handshake deals that evaporate. The agreement is documented before the inspection period closes, so it actually sticks.
  • A 3% listing fee and an Easy Exit Agreement. A lower fee leaves more room to absorb a fair credit when one saves the deal, and you can cancel at any time with no penalty if I am not performing.

The full step by step is on how I sell homes in Ocala. If you are weighing a repair request right now anywhere in Ocala, Belleview, or Summerfield, send me the report and I will build the counter.

Questions Sellers Ask

Inspection repair requests in Ocala, answered

Do I have to make repairs if I signed an AS-IS contract in Florida?

No. On the FAR/BAR AS-IS contract you owe zero repairs, and your only duty is to keep the home in substantially the same condition it was in on the effective date. The trade-off is that the buyer can still cancel during the inspection period and get their deposit back, so declining everything can cost you the deal.

Should I make the repairs or just give a closing credit?

A closing credit is usually cleaner. The buyer handles the work on their own schedule, your timeline stays tight, and the home still records at the full contract price instead of a lower one. Make the repairs yourself mainly when the buyer's lender requires it or when the fix is fast and cheap. A credit cannot exceed the buyer's actual costs or their loan's concession limit.

Can a buyer back out over the inspection in Florida?

Yes. On the AS-IS contract the buyer can cancel for any reason during the inspection period, which defaults to 15 calendar days, and keep their deposit. That right is where their repair leverage comes from, which is why a numbers-based counter usually beats a flat refusal.

Do I have to replace an old roof because the buyer asked?

Not for age alone. Florida insurers cannot refuse a policy on a roof under 15 years old based only on age, and for older roofs they must allow an inspection and cannot decline solely on age if it shows at least five years of life left. A specific leak or cracked tiles are fair to address. A blanket "replace it because it is old" is a weak demand you can usually counter with a wind mitigation report and a targeted repair.

What repairs are lenders most likely to require?

Active roof leaks, exposed or unsafe wiring, missing handrails or smoke detectors, standing water, and visible mold are common lender-called items, especially on FHA and VA loans. Those override the AS-IS language, because the loan will not fund until they are fixed. Your closing agent and the buyer's lender can confirm what their file needs.

How much should I expect to concede on a repair request?

There is no fixed number, but a healthy outcome is a fraction of the opening ask, covering the real safety, water, and system items and nothing cosmetic. I price every line with a licensed bid, set a small-dollar floor so we skip trivial items, and bring you a counter that protects the deal and your price. This is general information, not legal advice on your specific contract.

Does a repair credit lower my sale price?

No. A credit comes off what the buyer owes at closing, but the home still records at the full contract price, so your appraisal and the neighborhood comps stay intact. A price reduction does lower the recorded value. See seller concessions in Florida and more Ocala real estate questions.

Next Step

Got a repair request? Do not answer it alone

Send me the inspection report and the buyer's list. I will price it line by line, model the credit against a price cut on your real Ocala numbers, and write the counter that keeps the deal and your proceeds.

Or book a free 30 minute call